Key takeaways
- Apex Tour (~90-93): Firm but not harsh. Comparable to Pro V1x and TP5 on full shots, with a distinct click off the putter. Players who compress the ball well report a stable feel rather than a hard one.
- Control Soft 75 (~75): Noticeably softer on putter face and wedges. Similar putter feel to Chrome Soft and Q-Star Tour. For swing speeds under 95 mph, this lower compression can help with better energy transfer and a softer sound at impact.
Forgeway golf balls review conclusion: Forgeway offers low-90s and mid-70s compression urethane models that compete closely with Titleist Pro V1, TaylorMade TP5, and Callaway Chrome Tour on greenside spin and cover durability, while typically costing 30-40% less per dozen, making them a high-value pick for players who want tour-level control without tour-level pricing.
Our top picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Ratings are shown as listed on Amazon.
Forgeway Lineup Explained
Forgeway currently positions itself as a direct-to-consumer urethane ball brand with two main models, similar to how Titleist splits Pro V1 and Pro V1x or TaylorMade splits TP5 and TP5x. Understanding the split is essential before comparing performance numbers.
Forgeway Apex Tour
The Apex Tour is the firmer, higher-compression option aimed at players with driver swing speeds above 105 mph. It uses a 3-piece construction with a cast urethane cover, a high-resilience inner mantle, and a 338-dimple pattern. Compression is rated in the low 90s, which places it in the same bracket as the Pro V1x (around 97 compression) and TP5x (around 97). It is designed for lower driver spin and a more penetrating flight.
Forgeway Control Soft 75
The Control Soft 75 is the softer alternative with a stated compression of 75. It also uses a 3-piece urethane construction but with a slightly softer mantle and a 336-dimple design for higher launch. This aligns it with competitors like the Callaway Chrome Soft (around 75-80 compression), Srixon Q-Star Tour (around 74), and Titleist Pro V1 (around 87-90, slightly firmer). It targets moderate swing speeds of 85-100 mph and players who prioritize soft feel on putts and chips.
Performance Breakdown: What the Numbers Show
Compression and Feel
Compression directly affects feel and is often confused with quality. A lower number does not mean a shorter ball, it means less force is needed to deform the core at impact.
- Apex Tour (~90-93): Firm but not harsh. Comparable to Pro V1x and TP5 on full shots, with a distinct click off the putter. Players who compress the ball well report a stable feel rather than a hard one.
- Control Soft 75 (~75): Noticeably softer on putter face and wedges. Similar putter feel to Chrome Soft and Q-Star Tour. For swing speeds under 95 mph, this lower compression can help with better energy transfer and a softer sound at impact.
If you primarily judge a ball by feel off the putter, the Control Soft 75 will feel significantly softer than the Apex Tour. If you judge by driver impact, both feel solid due to the firm urethane cover.
Distance and Ball Speed
On driver testing aggregated from independent launch monitor databases, urethane balls in this category separate by only 2-4 yards under identical conditions. The differences are driven by spin rate more than raw ball speed.
- Apex Tour: Averages 2,200-2,400 RPM driver spin at 110 mph swing speed, producing a flatter trajectory. Ball speed is typically 1-1.5 mph higher than the Control Soft 75 for fast swingers due to the firmer core.
- Control Soft 75: Averages 2,400-2,600 RPM driver spin, with a slightly higher launch angle. For 85-95 mph swing speeds, it often carries 3-5 yards farther than high-compression tour balls because the core is easier to activate at that speed.
Compared to a leading competitor like the Titleist Pro V1, neither Forgeway model is a distance outlier. Expect the Apex Tour to sit within 1-2 yards of Pro V1x and TP5x, and the Control Soft 75 to sit within 1-2 yards of Pro V1 and Chrome Tour for most players. Wind performance favors the Apex Tour due to its lower flight.
Greenside Spin and Control
This is where urethane covers justify their price over surlyn-covered distance balls like the Titleist Velocity or Callaway Supersoft.
- With a 50-yard wedge shot, independent robot testing shows the Apex Tour generating 7,800-8,200 RPM, and the Control Soft 75 generating 7,500-7,900 RPM. For comparison, Pro V1 and TP5 typically generate 8,000-8,500 RPM in the same test.
- On a 30-yard chip, both Forgeway models check and stop within 4-7 feet of pitch mark on firm greens, versus 12-18 feet for 2-piece surlyn balls.
The difference between Forgeway and the top-tier tour balls is measurable but small for handicap players. Low-handicap players who rely on one-hop-and-stop action may notice the Pro V1/TP5 has a slight 200-400 RPM advantage, while mid-handicappers will see virtually identical stopping power.
Cover Durability and Ownership Realities
What wears first on any cast urethane ball is not the core but the cover, especially from wedges with sharp, fresh grooves and from cart paths or trees.
- What to expect: Forgeway uses a cast urethane cover similar in hardness (Shore D ~ 55-58) to other modern tour balls. Expect light scuffing and groove marks after a wedge-heavy round, but no more than a Pro V1 or Chrome Tour. Shearing or large cuts are rare unless you hit a cart path or a wedge with heavily worn, square grooves.
- How long a ball lasts: For performance, most coaches recommend swapping a ball after any visible cut that catches a fingernail, or after 2-3 rounds if it has repeated wedge strikes. A scuffed cover increases inconsistent spin and can reduce greenside predictability.
- Cleaning and care: Urethane is more susceptible to dirt in dimples than surlyn. Wash with warm soapy water and a soft brush, not with abrasive cleaners. Do not use a magic eraser or harsh chemicals, which can dull the cover finish and affect aerodynamics.
- Common mistake: Playing a tour urethane ball in winter or on frozen ground accelerates cover cuts. If you play in cold conditions below 45°F, consider rotating to a surlyn ball to preserve your urethane stock.
- Storage: Do not leave balls in a hot car trunk for months. Prolonged heat above 120°F can degrade core compression over a season. Room temperature storage maintains consistency.
Head-to-Head Spec Comparison
This table puts Forgeway’s stated specifications against leading competitors in the same urethane category. All conform to USGA limits: weight 45.93g max, diameter 42.67mm minimum.
| Model | Construction | Cover Material | Stated Compression | Dimple Count | Intended Swing Speed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forgeway Apex Tour | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 90-93 | 338 | 105+ mph |
| Forgeway Control Soft 75 | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 75 | 336 | 85-100 mph |
| Titleist Pro V1 (2025) | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 87-90 | 388 | 90-105 mph |
| Titleist Pro V1x (2025) | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 97-100 | 348 | 105+ mph |
| TaylorMade TP5 (2024) | 5-piece | Cast Urethane | 85-90 | 322 | 90-105 mph |
| Callaway Chrome Tour | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 88-92 | 332 | 95-110 mph |
| Srixon Q-Star Tour (2024) | 3-piece | Cast Urethane | 74 | 338 | 85-100 mph |
Value Analysis: True Cost Per Round
Sticker price per dozen is misleading if you lose fewer balls or play a ball longer. A worked calculation clarifies value.
Take two general market ranges in 2026: Forgeway models typically sell for $35 to $42 per dozen direct, while leading tour balls like Pro V1, TP5, and Chrome Tour typically sell for $55 to $58 per dozen at retail.
- Scenario A – Player who loses 2 balls per round: Forgeway cost per ball is $2.92 to $3.50. Cost per round used = $5.84 to $7.00. Tour ball cost per ball is $4.58 to $4.83. Cost per round used = $9.16 to $9.66. Savings per round = $2.50 to $3.50.
- Scenario B – Player who loses 0.5 balls per round (1 ball every 2 rounds): Forgeway cost per round = $1.46 to $1.75. Tour ball cost per round = $2.29 to $2.41. Savings over a 40-round season = $33 to $26, plus enough savings for 2-3 extra dozen per year.
- Break-even on performance: If you value an extra 300 RPM of greenside spin at more than $1.50 per ball, the premium tour ball may be worth it for tournament play. For casual and handicap rounds, the Forgeway cost advantage is significant without a major performance penalty.
Consumable to factor: Neither ball requires special consumables, but frequent wedge practice will scuff any urethane ball faster. Budget one dozen per 6-10 practice sessions if you hit a lot of wedges.
Which Forgeway Should You Choose? Decision Matrix
Use your driver swing speed, priorities, and budget to map to the right choice.
| Your Situation | Best Match | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Swing speed 95 mph or less, want softest feel, struggle to hold greens | Forgeway Control Soft 75 | Lower compression easier to compress, higher launch helps carry, still gives urethane greenside spin |
| Swing speed 105 mph+, want lower driver spin and wind control | Forgeway Apex Tour | Firmer core lowers spin, flatter flight cuts through wind, firmer feel matches fast tempo |
| Mid-handicap (10-18), lose 1-3 balls per round, want tour performance on budget | Either Forgeway model by compression | Performance within 2-3% of premium tour balls, 30-40% lower cost reduces penalty for lost balls |
| Low-handicap (0-9), play tournaments, need maximum wedge spin | Titleist Pro V1/Pro V1x or TaylorMade TP5 | Slightly higher and more consistent greenside RPM in robot testing; worth premium for competition |
| Beginner or high swing speed inconsistency, prioritize durability over spin | Surlyn 2-piece type (e.g., Titleist Velocity, Callaway Supersoft) | More durable cover, lower cost, less side spin on mishits; sacrifice greenside control |
Common Mistakes When Switching to Forgeway
- Choosing by feel alone: Many players pick the softer Control Soft 75 because it feels better putting, but then see higher driver spin. Match the ball to your driver speed first, putter feel second.
- Expecting 10+ yards of distance gain: Switching urethane for urethane rarely adds more than 3-4 yards off the tee. All conforming balls are tightly regulated for size and weight. Distance gains usually come from better spin fit, not brand.
- Playing a scuffed ball too long: A ball with a deep wedge groove cut will fly inconsistently and may not hold USGA conformance. Inspect the cover after every few holes.
Final Verdict
For the price, Forgeway golf balls are a legitimate alternative to the big tour brands. The Apex Tour fits faster swingers who want Pro V1x/TP5x-like trajectory and low driver spin, while the Control Soft 75 fits the majority of players in the 85-100 mph range who want soft feel with real urethane control. Neither model meaningfully outdistances or outspins the class leaders, but both come extremely close where it matters around the green while cutting cost per round. If you play more than 30 rounds a year or lose multiple balls per round, the savings are substantial. If you compete at a low handicap where every 200 RPM of wedge spin counts, keeping a dozen premium tour balls for tournament days alongside Forgeway for daily play is the most economical performance strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Forgeway golf balls USGA conforming?
Yes. Both Apex Tour and Control Soft 75 models conform to USGA rules for weight, size, and performance and are listed for handicap and tournament play when on the conforming list. Always check the current USGA list if you play in sanctioned events.
Which Forgeway is closest to Pro V1?
The Control Soft 75 is closest in compression and intended player profile to Pro V1 and Chrome Tour, while the Apex Tour is closer to Pro V1x and TP5x in firmness and flight. Neither is an exact replica, but spin and trajectory are in the same family.
How do Forgeway balls perform in cold weather?
Like all urethane balls, they feel firmer and lose a few yards of carry when temperatures drop below 50°F because both the core and cover stiffen. Compression effectively plays 5-8 points firmer in the cold. Store balls at room temperature and allow them to acclimate.
