In what has become an unspoken truth among critics and analysts alike, Cole Young, once considered the crown jewel of the Seattle Mariners’ future, may not be the player fans think he is. While fans continue to fawn over his potential, it’s time to take a hard look at the facts: Cole Young is not living up to the hype.
For years, Young has been touted as the “next big thing,” the player who would lead the Mariners into a new era of success. But the reality is far less glamorous. His performance on the field has been lackluster, and the expectations placed on him may be doing more harm than good. His offensive struggles this season have been glaring—poor batting averages, inconsistent power numbers, and an inability to come through in clutch situations. Let’s be honest, his numbers are hardly worthy of the top-tier praise he’s received. Is he really the best player on the team? A closer look suggests otherwise.
Defensively, the young shortstop has shown flashes of promise but has made enough errors to question his readiness to be a cornerstone player for Seattle. His defensive miscues have been costly, and his range—while decent—doesn’t quite live up to the standard of a star shortstop. Despite the hype, his glove has yet to make the type of impact Mariners fans were promised.
Fans may argue that Cole Young is still developing and has “untapped potential,” but this narrative is getting old. With every passing game, the idea that he’s somehow on the verge of greatness seems more and more like wishful thinking. His inconsistencies are being masked by lofty projections that don’t match up with the reality on the field. How much longer will Seattle’s front office allow him to “develop” while watching other teams surpass the Mariners in the standings?
It’s time for Mariners fans to face the truth: Cole Young may not be the savior they imagined. He may never live up to the high expectations thrust upon him. Perhaps it’s time to stop building him up as the next superstar and start asking the hard questions. Is he really the future of this team? Or is he just another player with unfulfilled potential who isn’t ready for the big stage? As the Mariners continue to struggle, the focus should shift away from Young’s potential and start concentrating on players who are ready to deliver, right now.
Leave a Reply